Journal of Psychological Assessment and Mental Health is committed to fair, rigorous and constructive peer review. This policy describes how manuscripts are evaluated and the responsibilities of everyone involved.
Model of review
The journal operates double-anonymous peer review: the identities of authors and reviewers are not disclosed to one another. Authors must submit an anonymised manuscript as described in the Author Guidelines.
The review process
- Editorial screening. The editorial office checks each submission for scope, completeness and adherence to policy; out-of-scope or non-compliant manuscripts may be returned or declined without external review.
- Assignment. A handling editor with relevant expertise is assigned.
- Independent review. The manuscript is normally evaluated by at least two independent expert reviewers assessing originality, theoretical grounding, methodological rigour, analysis, interpretation, ethics and contribution.
- Decision. The handling editor recommends a decision — accept, minor revision, major revision or decline. Final decisions rest with the editor and are communicated with the reviewers' comments.
- Revision. Authors respond point by point; revised manuscripts may be returned to reviewers.
Criteria and independence
Decisions are based on scholarly merit, soundness and transparency of methods, appropriateness of analysis, ethical conduct, clarity and fit with the journal's scope — never on the geographical origin, institution or perceived prestige of the authors. Editorial decisions rest solely with the journal's editors; the publisher does not intervene in individual decisions.
Reviewer responsibilities
- Treat manuscripts as strictly confidential and never share, distribute or upload them to third-party or AI tools (see the AI Policy).
- Declare any conflict of interest and decline where impartiality cannot be assured.
- Provide timely, evidence-based, constructive and respectful assessments.
Appeals and integrity
Authors may appeal a decision by contacting the editorial office with a reasoned response; appeals are considered by an editor not previously involved where possible. Concerns about the process or the work are handled under the Publication Ethics policy, consistent with COPE guidance. See also Complaints & Appeals.